You were walking to a store, and a car hit you in the parking lot. Now the driver’s insurance company is asking why you weren’t on the sidewalk.

In New York, getting hit by a car in a parking lot doesn’t make it your fault. State law requires every driver to use due care to avoid hitting a pedestrian, and that rule applies in shopping-plaza lots. Even if you share some blame, New York’s comparative fault rule lowers what you can recover. It doesn’t erase it.

Fault in parking-lot crashes is often disputed, and the evidence you gather early can make the difference. This article covers which laws apply, who is responsible, the deadlines you face and what to do next.

Key takeaways

  • Every driver must use due care to avoid colliding with a pedestrian (New York Vehicle and Traffic Law § 1146).
  • New York’s rules of the road, including the due care rule, apply in parking lots that serve stores and are open to the public (Vehicle and Traffic Law §§ 1100(a) and 129-b).
  • If you were partly at fault, your recovery is reduced by your share, not barred (Civil Practice Law and Rules § 1411).
  • A pedestrian hit by a car can claim no-fault benefits from the car’s insurer, but the written application is due within 30 days (11 NYCRR § 65-1.1).
  • You generally have three years from the crash to file a personal injury lawsuit, but the deadline is much shorter for a claim against a city, county or other public body (CPLR § 214(5); General Municipal Law § 50-i).

Do traffic laws apply in a parking lot?

Yes, most of them do. New York’s rules of the road apply on public highways, on private roads open to traffic, and in “parking lots,” which the law defines as private property serving stores or businesses and used by the public to park.

That definition comes from Vehicle and Traffic Law § 129-b. Section 1100(a) then extends the rules of the road to those lots. So a driver cutting through a plaza lot still has to follow the due care rule.

There are limits. Stop signs, yield signs, one-way arrows and turning rules painted in a lot only carry the force of law if the town, city or village has adopted them, under Section 1100(b). A lot that is private property limited to private use, like a gated employee lot, may fall outside these rules entirely. A lawyer can check which rules apply to the lot where you were hit.

Who is at fault when a car hits a pedestrian in a parking lot?

Usually the driver, but it depends on the facts. Section 1146 requires every driver to “exercise due care to avoid colliding with any… pedestrian.” Drivers also can’t back up unless they can do it safely (Vehicle and Traffic Law § 1211).
In a parking lot, fault often turns on questions like these:

  • Was the driver looking at a phone, the radio or a parking spot instead of the lane?
  • Was the driver speeding or cutting across empty spaces instead of following the drive lanes?
  • Did the driver back out without checking behind the car?
  • Could the driver have seen you in time to stop?

Pedestrians have duties too. But walking between cars to reach a store isn’t careless by itself. What matters is whether the driver used reasonable care in a place where people are always on foot.

What if the insurance company says I was partly at fault?

Your claim can still move forward. Under CPLR § 1411, your own share of fault reduces your damages in proportion to that share. It doesn’t block your claim.
Here’s how it works. If a jury valued your damages at $100,000 and found you 20% at fault, you could recover $80,000. The other side has to plead and prove your share of fault as an affirmative defense, meaning it’s their burden, not yours (CPLR § 1412).
An insurer raising comparative fault is a negotiating position, not a final ruling. Evidence like the police report, the ambulance record and surveillance video can answer it.

See also  Why Immediate Medical Care After a Car Crash Can Save Your Claim

Do I have a case?

You may have two claims, and they work differently.

No-fault benefits. New York’s no-fault insurance (also called Personal Injury Protection, or PIP) pays your medical bills and part of your lost wages up to $50,000, no matter who caused the crash. As a pedestrian, you claim these benefits through the insurer of the car that hit you.

A claim against the driver. To recover for pain and suffering, you need two things. First, the driver must be at fault. Second, your injury must meet New York’s “serious injury” threshold, a legal standard in Insurance Law § 5102(d). It includes fractures, significant disfigurement, a permanent limitation of a body organ or member, and a significant limitation of a body function or system.
Injuries that need surgery, like a spinal fusion, or that cause permanent limits often meet the threshold. The medical records have to show it, which is why consistent treatment matters.

How long do I have to act?

Some deadlines are short. Missing one can cost you benefits you’ve earned.

What Deadline Rule
Written no-fault application (Form NF-2) to the car’s insurer 30 days after the crash 11 NYCRR § 65-1.1
Notice of claim, if a city, county or other public body owned the car or the lot Generally 90 days General Municipal Law § 50-e
Lawsuit against a city, county or other public body Generally 1 year and 90 days General Municipal Law § 50-i
Personal injury lawsuit against the driver Generally 3 years CPLR § 214(5)

If you’re close to the 30-day mark, send the application now. A lawyer can check whether a late filing has a reasonable justification.

Three years can sound like plenty of time, but it’s best to talk to a lawyer as soon as you can. Surveillance video gets recorded over, vehicles get repaired and witnesses’ memories fade. The sooner a lawyer starts, the more evidence can be preserved.

Where does the money come from?

Usually the at-fault driver’s bodily injury liability policy. That policy has a limit, which is the most the insurer will pay for one person’s injuries. When an injury is serious, the policy limit often becomes the real ceiling on a settlement.
New York’s minimum is $25,000 per person, and many drivers carry only that. Your own auto policy may also include supplementary uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage (SUM). Whether SUM adds anything depends on your limits compared with the at-fault driver’s. It’s worth checking your declarations page now, before you need it.

What should I do now?

  1. Get medical care and follow your treatment plan, including follow-up visits and therapy.
  2. Report the crash to the police, and ask for the report number.
  3. File your no-fault application with the car’s insurer within 30 days.
  4. Write down what happened while you remember it: where the car came from, what the driver said and who saw it.
  5. Ask the store or plaza to preserve any surveillance video. Footage is often recorded over within days or weeks.
  6. Don’t give a recorded statement to the driver’s insurer before you get advice.
  7. Keep every bill, record and photo of your injuries in one place.

If you’d like a lawyer to look at what happened, you can tell us about your case.

How can a personal injury lawyer help?
A lawyer handles the parts of the claim that insurers dispute most: fault, the severity of your injury and how much coverage is available. At Hiller Comerford Injury & Disability Law, that work starts with getting the police report, the ambulance record and any video before it disappears. When a case needs it, we also hire investigators and experts.

See also  Why Identifying All Defendants in an Auto Accident Is Crucial

We also track your no-fault benefits and gather your medical records, so the file shows what the injury has cost you. If an insurer backs away from an earlier position on fault, that early evidence holds the claim together.

“In 2024, distracted driving killed 3,208 people and injured an estimated 315,167 more, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. Hundreds of those killed were pedestrians, cyclists and others who weren’t even in a car. Hiring an attorney right away after a collision not only preserves and enforces your rights but helps to make your community safe by holding people accountable who do not follow the traffic safety rules that protect us all from serious injury or death.”
— Charles H. Cobb, Esq., Personal Injury Attorney, Hiller Comerford

Hiller Comerford represents injured people across Western New York, from offices in Amherst, Buffalo, Williamsville, Orchard Park and Rochester. You can see some of our recent case results. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

You don’t have to sort this out alone

A parking-lot crash can feel like a gray zone. But New York law treats a lot like any place where drivers must watch for people on foot. If the insurer is questioning what happened, that’s when the facts matter most.

Were you hit by a car in a parking lot in New York? A Hiller Comerford attorney will review what happened, check every source of coverage and tell you where you stand. With our No Fee Guarantee, you never owe us a fee unless we recover for you. Tell us what happened →

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sue if I was hit by a car in a parking lot?

Yes, if the driver was at fault and your injury meets New York’s serious injury threshold. Drivers must use due care to avoid pedestrians, and that rule applies in parking lots that serve stores and are open to the public. No-fault benefits cover your medical bills either way.

Is a parking-lot accident always the driver’s fault?

No. Fault depends on what each person did. But drivers have a duty to watch for pedestrians, and walking through a lot to reach a store isn’t careless by itself. If you share some fault, New York reduces your recovery by your share instead of barring it.

Who pays my medical bills if a car hit me as a pedestrian?

The no-fault insurance on the car that hit you pays your medical bills and part of your lost wages, up to $50,000, regardless of fault. You must send a written application to that insurer within 30 days of the crash.

Do stop signs in a parking lot count?

Only if the local town, city or village has adopted them as enforceable rules under Vehicle and Traffic Law § 1100(b). The due care rule applies either way. A driver can still be at fault for hitting you, even if the lot’s signs aren’t enforceable.

What if the driver admitted fault and the insurer now denies it?

That happens. What the driver said at the scene may appear in the police report or the ambulance record. Those records are strong evidence, which is why getting them early matters. A lawyer can use them to answer the insurer’s new position.

How much is a parking-lot pedestrian case worth?

It depends on your injuries, your medical treatment, how the injury affects your life and how much insurance coverage is available. The at-fault driver’s policy limit often caps what an insurer will pay. A lawyer can identify every policy that applies.

Skip to content